Skip to main content

These friendships have something lacking (Rent-A-Girlfriend Ch. 245)

This week, we get a long overdue interlude with Kazuya confronting the fallout with Kibe after Paradise and the now-revealed secret of Chizuru’s true identity among their friends. This is a great opportunity to look back at Kazuya and Chizuru’s attitudes toward their friendships and how both sets of relationships have something lacking. Let’s take a look.

Kibe saying he’ll gut Kazuya is supposed to be a sweet moment. Mmkay.

Kazuya and validation

The big thing to remember about Kazuya is that his friends and family constantly doubt him. Recall that when Kuri and Kibe saw Kazuya with Chizuru, they immediately assumed she was trying to sell him something (or trying to get him involved in a cult). Played for laughs as this was, it is a constant theme in Kazuya’s relationships, as his family couldn’t believe Chizuru could be his girlfriend, either, and his father once assumed Kazuya could only be giving Chizuru money because he must’ve borrowed some from her before. In other words, Kazuya can do almost no good in their eyes. The only time he really ever got recognition from them was from Nagomi in Paradise, the culmination of a long string of doubts finally seen for what they were.

But Kibe doesn’t have that kind of epiphany. Here, he excuses Kazuya’s deception by saying… that Chizuru is worth it. This continuation of Kazuya’s friends and family having such Chizuru-centered morality is disturbing at best, compounded by how he says that Kazuya better make it work or else. I get that Kibe doesn’t want to see what they went through be for nothing, but this is warped. There’s really no way around it. And Kibe doesn’t bring himself to do what Nagomi did, which is apologize to Kazuya in turn for having saddled him with the weight of being a disappointment again and again and again. As much as Kazuya sees Kibe as a good friend, Kazuya cannot see that all these people around him (except, crucially, Chizuru, and maybe his mother) treat him as a fuckup first.

Chizuru and her… friends?

Chizuru said she would reveal the truth to her friends… if she had to. (105)

Chizuru’s relationship with her friends has always been strange. We’ve never gotten the real sense that Chizuru was actually close with her school friends. Kazuya speaks out here assuring Sasano that Chizuru isn’t putting on a facade for them, but his assurances can only go so far. They didn’t know Chizuru was an actress before (at least, Kazuya mentioned they might find out, and Chizuru said she would come clean to them after if they did find out).

One can rightly get the impression that Chizuru isn’t really friends with these girls beyond a surface level. That stands in contrast to her acting friends: we’ve seen her trade messages and talk with Shiori (244), the girl she did her first play with before. We also know she would go shopping with Umi (124), ostensibly for more than just Kazuya’s phone case.

And yet now we are primed to look at Chizuru’s relationship with her school friends more closely. Will Kazuya actually bring up this point, and how would Chizuru act on it? This is a bit of a mystery since we don’t know how they are truly important to her, if at all. It’s also not clear that this is a point that will come up while Chizuru is taking Kazuya to her grandma’s house.

So, in one case, we see a friendship that doesn’t seem to acknowledge how imbalanced it is, with Kibe and Kazuya not even considering that Kibe has mistreated Kazuya in any way. In another, we can’t even be sure Chizuru values her school friendships whatsoever. These unbalanced relationships leave some tension still in the story going forward.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

It was all for nothing: A Rent-A-Girlfriend Paradise retrospective

The Paradise Arc came to a close this week. It was, without a doubt, Miyajima’s most ambitious arc yet: the only named arc in the series to go more than 10 chapters (43, in fact, and 44 in total if you count Mami’s backstory). It was Miyajima’s Infinity War and Endgame , a massive collision of multiple plotlines all being brought to fruition over two days in Fukushima, but in the end, we see what it was really all about: Chizuru coming to grips with the fact that she has fallen in love with Kazuya and can no longer ignore her feelings. Love's taken root, but is it bearing satisfying fruit? And… that’s all it was. Chizuru was beaten over the head with a narrative baseball bat until she got it , put under so much pressure that she finally couldn’t ignore her true feelings, but in doing so, Miyajima overlooked or outright ignored the major themes of his series. Kazuya and Chizuru replaced one lie with another, not because it was something they felt they believed in but simply ...

Does Chizuru even love Kazuya for who he is? (Rent-A-Girlfriend Ch. 246)

This past week on Rent-A-Girlfriend , Chizuru brought Kazuya to her childhood home, and much of how Kazuya acted reminded her once again of her departed grandfather, Katsuhito. Kazuya’s supportive attitude and optimism (at least when it comes to anything outside himself) are traits he shares with Katsuhito, and the association between Katsuhito and Kazuya has been explicit ever since Katsuhito’s introductory arc. Moreover, it was heavily implied, retroactively at least, that Chizuru took a liking to Kazuya and cut him a lot of slack in part because his attitude toward his family is relatable to her. In other words, Chizuru felt comfortable with Kazuya (to an extent) from the start because he reminded her of Katsuhito. Seeing Kazuya spare no effort, just like Katsuhito once did, Chizuru can’t help but remember… Given how strongly Kazuya has paralleled Katsuhito, it’s valid to ask, then, whether Chizuru really loves anything about Kazuya at all outside of that feel...

No longer lonely... and now with even more to lose (Rent-A-Girlfriend's cohabitation arc, chs. 256-261)

One of the things I think useful about looking back an entire sequence of chapters now, instead of the weekly breakdowns, is the ability to put things in perspective. We sat through 6 chapters of Rent-A-Girlfriend doing its best slice of life comedy impression, and now we’re back in soap opera mode, raising the opportunity for a higher-stakes clash now that we see what Kazuya and Chizuru have to lose. Chizuru can now smile about this situation, with no regrets. (261) Accepting Kazuya closer to her heart We saw back in ch. 250 how Chizuru felt alone and disconnected , having had to move away from Kazuya and into the empty house her grandma left behind. That sense of isolation led her to contemplate reaching out to Kazuya, to go out past her bedtime to see him when given the slightest reason, and to accept the opportunity host him at her home—at least for the next month. Chizuru has emerged from the first few days of their new arrangement all the brighter for it. S...